skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Last
month I reported on the looming expiration of the Bush tax cuts at the
end of this year. Included in these expiring cuts is the Mortgage Debt
Relief act. This provision, passed into law in 2007, allows an
exemption from taxes for people who have lost their home through
foreclosure or short sale and have received forgiveness from the banks
for the portion of their debt that was not covered by the foreclosure
auction or short sale. If the tax cuts are allowed to expire without
modification or extension, then the Mortgage Debt Relief act would also
expire. This expiration would mean that any homeowner receiving
forgiveness for a portion of the amount owed on their mortgage, whether
through short sale, foreclosure, loan modification would be required to
pay taxes to the Federal Government on this amount as if it were regular
income.Although
there is widespread bi-partisan support in both houses for an extension
of the Mortgage Debt Relief act, it is still not certain that this act
will, in fact, be extended. The reason for this can be found in the
figures behind the law. Although we do not have data available to show
exactly how much total debt homeowners have been forgiven in the last
five years, we do know that the Congressional Budget Office has
estimated that allowing the exclusion to expire would generate around
$1.3 billion in taxes from affected homeowners. According to Brian
Bernardoni, senior director of government and public policy at the
Chicago Association of Realtors, this juxtaposition between what is best
for homeowners and what is best for a government struggling to combat a
huge deficit is what keeps the extension of the Mortgage Debt Relief
act in doubt. Bernardoni notes, “This could be one of the unintended
consequences of a deal to avoid the fiscal cliff. Singling out any one
group for tax relief is going to be difficult.”There
is a bit of the chicken and the egg paradigm at work here. Some
lawmakers believe that the health of the overall economy must be
considered over the interests of a particular group of citizens or a
particular sector of the economy. Others believe that the health of the
housing market is so directly tied to the recovery of the economy at
large that failure to extend this measure could prove debilitating to
the entire recovery effort. Mesirow Financial’s Diane Swonk puts it
this way, “Housing is finally showing signs of healing after a prolonged
illness...We still have a long way to go, but it has reached a critical
shift in momentum, if allowed to continue; the choice is in the hands
of our elected officials, and the clock is ticking.”I
will continue to update my readers on the status of all negotiations in
Congress, and their potential impact on the housing markets, as those
details become available.
Regardless
of which box you are checking in the upcoming election, you should be
aware that the expiring Bush tax cuts, made famous by the recent
presidential debates, include a provision that excludes mortgage debt
relief from taxation up to a maximum of $2 million. If the Bush tax
cuts are allowed to expire, the Mortgage Debt Relief Act will expire
with them. This means that homeowners who have received reductions in
their mortgage debt either via short sales or loan modifications will be
required to pay income tax on the amount of principal that was
forgiven. According to a recent article in The Chicago Tribune, this
would amount to around $19,000 in taxes owed for the average middle
class relief settlement.There
appears to be bi-partisan support in both houses for extending the
mortgage debt relief portion of the Bush tax cuts for another several
years, but without extending the rest of the cuts it seems unlikely that
a bill supporting the extension of just the mortgage debt relief
portion will even reach a vote prior to the November elections. This
is especially bad timing when you consider that the nation’s five
largest banks (Bank of America Corp., JPMorgan Chase & Co., Wells
Fargo & Co., Citigroup Inc. and Ally Financial Inc.) have recently
increased their offerings of principal reductions and other relief to
homeowners as part of a $25 billion settlement with federal and state
officials over foreclosure abuse allegations. If the Bush tax cuts,
including the mortgage debt relief act, do expire then these principal reductions will be reported to the IRS and will appear on homeowners’ tax returns as income.Experts
agree that while the housing market shows signs of stabilization,
extending these tax cuts is vitally important to keeping the housing
recovery on track. "Extending this tax relief is critically important,"
said Lynda Gledhill, a spokeswoman for California Attorney General
Kamala Harris. Harris was a key player in the national mortgage
settlement. "It is difficult to imagine strapped homeowners able to
take advantage of these and other market-restoring programs if they have
to pay federal income tax on the principal reduction or short sale as
'income,'" Gledhill said.My
personal opinion is that we will probably see Congress find a way to
extend these tax cuts for another 6 months to a year, much as they
extended the first time home buyer credit in 2010-2011. Regardless, one
thing is certain. If you are even remotely considering selling your
home via a short sale, now is the time to do it. If you are able to
close before the end of the year, you know that you will be able to take
advantage of the tax credit.